The Needs of Children in Transgender Families

Written by Cynthia Young LMFT

Above all, children need to know that you are OK. If you are struggling and feeling like you might not win the struggle, don't do it alone. Get help for yourself. Your child will benefit from it too! Here are some more of the basics:

1. Children. like adults. need to feel good about themselves. They need to feel that they are good people, that they are lovable, and that they are loved. Translated, this means that Transgender (TG) families should make an effort to help the children understand that the TG family member's condition is:

a) Not caused by the child or the child's actions or decisions or thoughts.
b) Not "curable" by the child, no matter how good they are and no matter what sacrifices and promises they make.

Some children, especially older children, may interpret the adult's decision to begin transition as a sign that the adult does not love the child enough to delay or reject transition. The child may not say this out loud because the thought is too painful to accept. Anticipate this unhappy thought and explain that the love of the child was one of the most important factors in putting off transition this long! The urge to become alike inside and out is so strong that it is a miracle that it didn't happen long ago.

2. Children need information. What they wonder about and do not know they will make up. What they make up may be based on serious misinformation or fears. Giving them information that is age appropriate is very important. Children are learning machines. Therefore, they take in a lot of information through their eyes and ears. It would be a mistake to assume that little Sheila or Joshua doesn't notice remnants of nail polish or lipstick or pierced ears on dad. They notice things that are unusual in their environment and they will make assumptions about what they notice. Very small children may assume, correctly, that there are a wide range of behaviors and modes of dress that are appropriate for moms and dads. Because they make no judgment about these things, they are more likely to point out what they notice. ("Daddy's wearing earrings like Mommy!") Older children have already absorbed lots of social information about sex role behaviors and may be making judgments about what they see based on this information. Because these judgments may be uncomfortable for them, they are less likely to let you know what they notice.

If you have had good communication with your child in the past, and you have been able to talk about difficult things without you becoming embarrassed or defensive or angry or shaming or authoritarian or getting your feelings hurt, you have already laid the foundation for talking about the family gender issues. You have taught your child that you are a SAFE listener and you are inviting your child to ask questions and make comments. Your child knows that they can get straight information from you without a lot of emotional baggage attached to it. If you have not been a high scorer in this area, you will want to improve your listening skills. A book that can help you do this is, "How to Talk so Kids will Listen and Listen so Kids will Talk".

Even if your child is not asking questions, there will be certain information that, from time to time, you will need to give them. Try writing it down first. Then read it as if you were in your child's shoes. Consult with someone else to be sure you are not providing too much information and that you have put it in a way that a child of your child's age can understand. Practice giving this information out loud until you feel comfortable (so your child will be comfortable too). Always tell your child that all questions and comments are welcome.

3. Children need to be children, not adults. They are not equipped to be emotionally responsible for you. Parents who become martyrs invite their children to take care of them emotionally. Let your child know that, no matter what decisions you make and no matter what the outcome of these decisions, they are your decisions and you are strong enough to take care of yourself. It is OK for you to be honest with them about your feelings, but let them know that you can handle these feelings yourself. Your child does not need to do anything to make you happier or calmer or less worried.

Children need to be engaged in developmentally appropriate activities. The family TG issues or a family member's transition should not get in the way of these important matters. Playing with other kids, going to basketball practice, getting outfitted for the prom and other activities go on. Reassure your child that his or her life will go on normally. If you find that is not happening, consider what steps you need to take to remedy that.

4. Children need to live out of war zones. A war zone exists if the adults speak of one another with disrespect or sarcasm, "clever" double meanings, and similar verbal barbs. In an environment like this, your child has no safe place to express him or herself. Any comment at all could be viewed as disloyal to one side or the other. To be disloyal is to risk rejection!!! Your child may feel invited to agree with whoever they are with - and feel guilty about it later. Another child will feel compelled to stand up for the maligned parent and take on adult mediation responsibilities that cannot help but fail and leave the child feeling responsible. You don't want your child to be placed in this position If you have already done this, explain to your child that you were wrong. You will be setting a good example. Your child does not need you to be perfect.

5. Children need to feel important. That means that they need to know they have an influence over you and some power over their environment Their needs and reasonable wishes should be met. If that does not happen, your child will get the message that he or she is not important to you. This sows the seeds for low self esteem, for future depression and destructive rebellion. If your daughter requests that you do not wear make up when her new boy friend comes over for the first time, carefully weigh the consequences to both of you of that decision. If your son comes to you and asks you not to belittle dads efforts to appear to feminine, consider the costs to your relationship of ignoring this request.

6. Children need to feel their own feelings. Your shame is contagious! If you are feeling ashamed of yourself or your family member, your child may take on your shame. It is not a good idea to begin transition if you are still dealing with significant levels of shame. Attack that in your own therapy. Family members who see the TG issues as reflecting on them in a negative way also have work to do to get past their shame and start to feel good about themselves. A family member's transgender status is no reflection at all on the children in the family and they should be given every opportunity to avoid taking on your shame because of it. Your anger, your worry, your sadness and Your helplessness don't belong to your children either. Do share your true feelings and be clear that they are YOUR feelings right now, that they change over time, and that your child does not have to feel the same way. Encourage your child to share his or her feelings. If your child does not want to share them with you, be sure and tell them it is OK, even a good idea, to share them with somebody else. Tell them there are no wrong feelings for them to have.

7. Children need to be heard. It is your job to become the best listener you can be. (See No. 2. above.) If your child still does not let you know his or her thoughts and feelings and questions, make sure there is somebody else available for them. Old patterns die hard. If your child is too concerned with hurting your feelings or bringing on your anger, don't try to pry their thoughts out of them. Just keep practicing your listening skills, be patient and try to feel good that your child has someone to confide in even if it is not you.

8. Children need to know they will not lose you. Families often change configuration when a family member reveals that he or she is transgendered. If a divorce or separation is being considered in your family or if someone is threatening to cut off relations with other members of the family because of TG issues it is especially important to reassure children that you will not leave them and you will not take them away from anyone else who is important to them. Transgenderism in a family member should not translate to losses for the children. They didn't ask for it either!

9. Children need to know that they are not transgendered Give them age appropriate information about what transgenderism is. Let them know they cannot catch it, and that it is a very rare condition that does not run in families and cannot be inherited.

10. Children need to know that transgenderism is a normal human variation. Transgendered persons have always been among us. Transgenderism is not a moral issue, nor is it about character or willpower. It is not a voluntary condition. Transgenderism is a medical condition that people are born with. Children old enough to understand the gestation process can understand that boys and girls begin life the same. While they are growing inside the mother they slowly develop into different sexes. This involves changes in both the body and the brain. Very rarely the changes go in different directions and boys have brains more like girls and girls have brains more like boys. Sometimes the differences between brain and body are so great that the person feels very uncomfortable in their body and living the sex role that matches their body. Sometimes the best way to correct this condition is to change the body to match the brain. It is not possible to change the brain to match the body. Sometimes it is possible for the transgendered person to live a life that matches the brain without changing the body. Very often dressing in the clothes of the sex that matches the brain is very important for the transgendered individual's emotional well-being. Only the transgendered person can decide how much and what kind of change is needed.

Families need to work together to help children deal with the following: Strategies will differ depending on the child's age and circumstances.

Social Stigma and teasing by other children:
*How can the child stand up to the ignorance of others and maintain high self esteem?

School:
*What information should be shared with school personnel and teachers? When and how? *How much and what kind of involvement should the transgendered person have with the child's school?

Friends and Friend's Families:
*Who to tell, how much to tell and when and how to tell it.

Other family members:
*How can the child deal with family members who are angry and uncooperative?

All families face challenges. No children have perfect lives. It is the way we face challenge and what we learn from it that determines how resilient we will be in life. Children learn by our examples. What would you like the child in your life to learn about him or herself and about others from the experience of having a transgendered family member? What will your example teach?

(This document may not be reproduced or distributed without the author’s written permission.)

(Thank You! to Cynthia Young for allowing me to reprint this excellent document! - Jenni)

This page was updated August 7, 2001

Back to top...


This Site, the Journal, and all related pages, are copyrighted 1997-2003 by Jennifer O except as noted. All rights reserved. This Document may not be reproduced in any form without the author's written permission.